Black unemployment

Study: Some jobs suck so bad that it’s worse than being unemployed

Study: Some jobs suck so bad that it’s worse than being unemployed

Reported by Michal Ortner

While the job market has been looking up and more people seem to be finding temporary and long-term positions, some researchers are wondering if this has created new psychosocial problems in a vast majority of workers. This poses an issue for production rates and overall competency for those who are in temporary situations, especially if they feel their job is menial.

According to Mashable writer Stephen Bevan, “Psychosocial job quality involves the degree to which jobs promote control, autonomy, challenge, variety and task discretion. It affects the extent to which work enhances or diminishes our psychological well-being.”

A survey in Australia conducted by The Household, Income and Labor Dynamics in Australia (HILDA) provided data that shows what is to be gained when a person is engaged in a fulfilling position. According the results of the research, “Overall, unemployment respondents had poorer mental health than those who were employed. However, the mental health of those who were unemployed was comparable or superior to those jobs of the poorest psychosocial quality.”

“Those who moved into optimal jobs showed significant improvement in mental health compared to those who remained unemployed. Those respondents who moved into poor-quality jobs showed a significant worsening in their mental health compared to those who remained unemployed,” the data also found.

Bevan makes a point when he writes that “we should probably question whether the revolving-door characteristics of some policies in which many people fall back out of work soon after being found a job might — in part — owe their poor performance to the damaging psychosocial quality of the work itself.”

In the U.K., there is a program called “zero-hour” that is supposed to benefit both the employer and employee. The employer is able to find a worker quickly and does not deal with a contract, and the employee can begin working immediately, though for an unknown amount of time.

“The context for zero-hours working is a long-term trend towards more flexible and diverse forms of work capable of meeting the needs of employers and individuals,” states a report by CIPD that was gathered through the Labour Market Outlook and Employee Outlook.

The problem with the new concept of flexibility for employment comes when a worker needs more stability to pay bills. Some workers report that they can be turned down for housing because their income is “too risky.” This type of adversity adds a stress marker to the employee.

The research done by HILDA concludes that “work of poor psychosocial quality does not bestow the same mental health benefits as employment in jobs with high psychosocial quality.”



Source 1, 2

  • Black unemployment

    FJT aims to be the information hub that empowers Black wealth creation. We are behind FJT's fresh & insightful content that helps you think, learn, laugh, and move towards action to create a stronger Black community.

    More in Black unemployment

    The Vet Life stars serve up prescription for business success

    zacharyJanuary 12, 2018

    Are co-workers getting on your nerves? Try these tips to overcome workplace conflict.

    zacharyApril 12, 2017

    Dr Boyce Watkins: Here’s why black college students end up being screwed at predominantly white universities

    FJT StaffJanuary 2, 2017

    Dear Black People: You have the ability to employ your own people

    FJT StaffAugust 13, 2016

    Take a look at the petition to fire Jesse Williams over his speech at the BET Awards

    FJT StaffJuly 3, 2016

    I just saw Will Smith’s “Pursuit of Happyness,” and it made me VERY uncomfortable

    FJT StaffMay 30, 2016